• English

Uzbekistan2030.uz

DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY
CENTER
Development Strategy center

ELDOR TULYAKOV: “MUCH NEEDS TO BE DONE TO ENHANCE THE ROLE OF SOCIETY IN ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE”


The Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan is currently hosting a round table discussion. The participants discuss priority areas outlined in the report of President Shavkat Mirziyoyev at the grand meeting on the 27th anniversary of adoption of the Constitution of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The discussion was organized jointly with the Supreme Court of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Development Strategy Center, National Center for Human Rights and the OSCE Project Coordinator in Uzbekistan. Executive Director of the Development Strategy Center Eldor Tulyakov drew attention to the features and relevant aspects of foreign experience in conducting civic control in the judicial system.

Eldor Tulyakov, Executive Director of the Development Strategy Center:

“There is much to do to further ensure the transparency of the judiciary, to expand open dialogue with the public, and to strengthen the role of society in the administration of justice. In this context, it is advisable to comprehensively study best international practices and experience of developed countries, and introduce applicable aspects into the judicial system of our country.

In France, for instance, serious crimes committed by minors are considered with the participation of three qualified judges and nine judicial advisers. If a judge considers cases of criminal acts of minors alone without judicial advisers, then he has the right to apply solely educational and supervisory measures to the defendant. In England, forensic counselors are involved in investigating murder-related crimes in cases where the cause of an unnatural or unintentional death was not established. In Japan, people’s judges are entitled to participate in serious criminal cases as judges. In such cases, the judiciary consists of six people’s judges and three professional judges. The accused does not have the right to refuse a people’s judge. In most European countries, judicial advisers, together with a professional judge, decide on the guilt or innocence of the defendant, as well as on the imposition of punishment.

Ultimately, various models of public participation in fair trials in the developed foreign countries foster the enhancement of public confidence in the judicial system, protecting the interests of citizens in the process of organizing and conducting a fair trial.